A friend has recently encouraged me to look at Scrivener as a possible alternative to Info Select, a Personal Information Manager (PIM) that I have been using for nigh on fifteen years, and in which I have invested very heavily (by this I mean that I have enormous amounts of information entered in Info Select, 100mg or so of text in approximately 34,000 individuals notes. The ‘notes’ in IS are equivalent to the ‘text’ entries in Scrivener).
What I am wondering is whether anyone here has experience of Info Select and is also conversant with Scrivener.
In particular I am interested in how Scrivener might cope with large amounts of data. I am a historian who works with large amounts of evidence, much of it in the form of snippets of information. My subject is the society of Renaissance Italy. Perhaps the best comparison would be with the archaeologist of an ancient culture, who accumulates hundreds of small pieces of data, and who then combines them painstakingly to create a portrait of the society s/he studies. Info Select has been a great boon to me for many years because of its lightning fast searches. Apparently like Scrivener, it doesn’t need tags: you can search for any character string and it will immediately extract all occurrences of that string, presenting them much in the way that Scrivener uses the Binder. The hits in the search are highlighted in the text wherever they occur.
I like the look of Scrivener very much, but my first impression is perhaps that, because Scrivener is based on individual projects, that it’s not really designed to be a massive bin into which one drops information for later retrieval (I often collect information without knowing exactly how I am going to use it. The context emerges in the later writing and thinking - this is why the powerful search function is so important to me).
Can Scrivener handle really large amounts of information?
How powerful is its search function?
Will it dig down deep into sub-folders of sub-folders to extract search strings from text that might have entered into the programme years before (Info Select does this brilliantly)? I am very interested in any feedback Scrivener uses might have.
Why am I looking at Scrivener if Info Select is so good? The project-writing dimension of Scrivener is clearly superior to IS. The manufacturers of IS seem not to be supporting their product as well as they once did, and they have in recent times crammed bells and whistles into the programme that somewhat obscure its original simplicity.
I would be grateful for comments - thank you in advance.